The Future of Fine Wine Investment: Navigating a $100 Billion Market
"Fine wine is not just a passion; it's a strategic asset. With annualized returns of 10% over the last 30 years, wine has proven its value as a stable, long-term investment that can diversify and strengthen any portfolio."
"Fine wine is not just a passion; it's a strategic asset. With annualized returns of 10% over the last 30 years, wine has proven its value as a stable, long-term investment that can diversify and strengthen any portfolio."
"Fine wine is not just a passion; it's a strategic asset. With annualized returns of 10% over the last 30 years, wine has proven its value as a stable, long-term investment that can diversify and strengthen any portfolio."
Introduction
When it comes to investing in rare fine wine, High Net Worth Individuals (HNWIs) often face a delicate balance between passion and pragmatism. For Sam Mudie, CEO of Savea, fine wine transcends mere capital growth, morphing into an obsession that unites people through craftsmanship and history. Yet, for those keen on long-term value appreciation, it’s critical to approach wine investment with an objective, strategic mindset.
As Mudie advises, “It’s crucial to separate heart from head." He emphasizes that personal preferences must be put aside, no matter how strong your love for certain regions or varietals may be. For instance, while one may not enjoy drinking Pinot Noir, the hard data from Liv-ex’s Burgundy 150 index shows an annualized return of 10% over the last 30 years. That’s a number impossible to ignore.
Strategic Diversification: A Recipe for Success
Diversification is key when it comes to wine investment. "Traditional collectors may focus on a few favourite regions or producers, but investors need a more strategic allocation," Mudie notes. Wine regions like Bordeaux, Burgundy, Champagne, and Tuscany are mainstays of fine wine investment, while emerging areas like Piedmont and Napa Valley provide unique opportunities. The trick is balancing producers and vintages to ensure price stability across market conditions. A diversified approach not only mitigates risk but also helps build a robust portfolio in a dynamic market.
Undervalued Regions: Where to Invest Next?
For those seeking undervalued regions, Mudie cautions against a hasty rush into Bordeaux, despite a 16% dip in the last two years. He explains, “Several overpriced vintage releases since 2021 have flooded the market, and a significant amount of stock remains unsold.” He advises holding off on Bordeaux investments until possibly mid-next year.
Burgundy and Champagne have come down approximately 25% from their peak in September 2022 and prices appear to be supported by very low supply, making them particularly attractive for investors looking for a likely market turn. "For these regions, now is an opportune moment to invest across most vintages," says Mudie.
Avoiding Novice Pitfalls
The allure of certain vintages often leads novice investors astray. According to Mudie, “One common mistake is assuming that the best vintage makes the best investment.” In reality, relative value and market sentiment are far more critical. As an example, he highlights the difference between Bordeaux’s 2010 and 2013 Lafite Rothschild vintages. While 2010 is regarded as a superior vintage, the 2013 vintage saw a 172% return between 2015 and 2022, compared to just 68% for the 2010 vintage. The key to this success was its lower starting price and the Hong Kong market's emphasis on brand over vintage quality at that time.
Portfolio Allocation: Where Does Wine Fit?
For HNWIs interested in adding wine to their broader investment portfolio, Mudie recommends integrating it within a diversified strategy. "Wealth managers typically suggest allocating around 20% to alternatives, which includes wine," Mudie says. While there's no one-size-fits-all rule, he stresses the importance of maintaining traditional, liquid assets alongside fine wine investments. A typical portfolio may include 40% in equities, 25% in bonds, 15% in property, and 20% in alternatives like wine, gold, or crypto.
The Role of Provenance and Storage
When it comes to safeguarding investments Mudie states, “provenance and storage are critical to preserving a wine’s value.,” Fine wine must be sourced from official channels and stored professionally, ideally in UK bond with full insurance coverage. “Buying from individual collectors can be risky, especially when wine is stored in home cellars or wine fridges,” he cautions. For top-tier investments, professional storage and full provenance documentation are non-negotiable.
Climate Change: A Game-Changer for Wine Investment
Climate change is reshaping the wine world, and Mudie foresees its profound impact on rare wine values. "Extreme weather patterns are already driving up the value of rare wines," he points out. Frosts, droughts, and heatwaves are reducing yields and pushing up production costs. Mudie gives a striking example: “In 2021, frosts devastated up to 80% of production in parts of Bordeaux, Burgundy, and Champagne.”
As climate patterns become more erratic, Old World regions like Bordeaux and Burgundy will face increasing challenges. Meanwhile, cooler climate regions such as New Zealand, Canada, and even England are rising in prominence. However, while their wines are improving, Mudie remains cautious. "They are unlikely to be considered investment-grade anytime soon."
Emerging Markets: Beyond Bordeaux and Burgundy
Savvy investors looking beyond traditional powerhouses like Bordeaux and Burgundy should pay attention to Piedmont, according to Mudie. Particularly known for its Barolo, Piedmont’s Nebbiolo grape shares economic similarities with Burgundy’s Pinot Noir—both rely on single varietals that are difficult to grow and have a significant supply-demand imbalance. "As the price gap between Burgundy and Piedmont widens, the latter could attract a counterculture of collectors who avoid high-production regions like Bordeaux,” Mudie notes.
Expert Guidance: The Key to Success
Investing in fine wine is a sophisticated endeavor, and expert guidance can make all the difference. "Even in the stock market, where investors are rarely emotionally attached, it's difficult to remain objective," Mudie says. In the wine market, the challenge is magnified due to asymmetric access to information and the complexity of managing diverse portfolios.
For those seeking a hands-off approach, Savea offers a unique solution. Through innovative tokenization and smart contracts, Savea provides a scalable option for wine investors. "By replicating the performance of the Liv-ex 1000 index, which has averaged +7% annually over the last 20 years, Savea offers investors exposure to the asset class with lower costs, improved liquidity, and minimal barriers to entry—without the need to own the physical wine," explains Mudie.
As the fine wine market evolves, so too must the strategies of those investing in it. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a novice investor, the insights offered by Savea’s CEO Sam Mudie serve as a roadmap for successfully navigating the complex world of wine investment.
About the Author
Sam Mudie has worked in wine investment since 2012, including nine years with the world’s largest specialist advisor, Cult Wines, with US$360m assets under management. He founded the Singapore office, managed the business across Southeast Asia and was on the Investment Committee. During this time, he built up a large network of individuals with interests in various ‘passions assets’ such as wine, whisky, watches, art and cars. Sam has been featured in Robb Report, Forbes, MoneyFM, The Peak and CNA, and was previously a member of the British Chamber of Commerce’s Finance and Fintech Committee.
Introduction
When it comes to investing in rare fine wine, High Net Worth Individuals (HNWIs) often face a delicate balance between passion and pragmatism. For Sam Mudie, CEO of Savea, fine wine transcends mere capital growth, morphing into an obsession that unites people through craftsmanship and history. Yet, for those keen on long-term value appreciation, it’s critical to approach wine investment with an objective, strategic mindset.
As Mudie advises, “It’s crucial to separate heart from head." He emphasizes that personal preferences must be put aside, no matter how strong your love for certain regions or varietals may be. For instance, while one may not enjoy drinking Pinot Noir, the hard data from Liv-ex’s Burgundy 150 index shows an annualized return of 10% over the last 30 years. That’s a number impossible to ignore.
Strategic Diversification: A Recipe for Success
Diversification is key when it comes to wine investment. "Traditional collectors may focus on a few favourite regions or producers, but investors need a more strategic allocation," Mudie notes. Wine regions like Bordeaux, Burgundy, Champagne, and Tuscany are mainstays of fine wine investment, while emerging areas like Piedmont and Napa Valley provide unique opportunities. The trick is balancing producers and vintages to ensure price stability across market conditions. A diversified approach not only mitigates risk but also helps build a robust portfolio in a dynamic market.
Undervalued Regions: Where to Invest Next?
For those seeking undervalued regions, Mudie cautions against a hasty rush into Bordeaux, despite a 16% dip in the last two years. He explains, “Several overpriced vintage releases since 2021 have flooded the market, and a significant amount of stock remains unsold.” He advises holding off on Bordeaux investments until possibly mid-next year.
Burgundy and Champagne have come down approximately 25% from their peak in September 2022 and prices appear to be supported by very low supply, making them particularly attractive for investors looking for a likely market turn. "For these regions, now is an opportune moment to invest across most vintages," says Mudie.
Avoiding Novice Pitfalls
The allure of certain vintages often leads novice investors astray. According to Mudie, “One common mistake is assuming that the best vintage makes the best investment.” In reality, relative value and market sentiment are far more critical. As an example, he highlights the difference between Bordeaux’s 2010 and 2013 Lafite Rothschild vintages. While 2010 is regarded as a superior vintage, the 2013 vintage saw a 172% return between 2015 and 2022, compared to just 68% for the 2010 vintage. The key to this success was its lower starting price and the Hong Kong market's emphasis on brand over vintage quality at that time.
Portfolio Allocation: Where Does Wine Fit?
For HNWIs interested in adding wine to their broader investment portfolio, Mudie recommends integrating it within a diversified strategy. "Wealth managers typically suggest allocating around 20% to alternatives, which includes wine," Mudie says. While there's no one-size-fits-all rule, he stresses the importance of maintaining traditional, liquid assets alongside fine wine investments. A typical portfolio may include 40% in equities, 25% in bonds, 15% in property, and 20% in alternatives like wine, gold, or crypto.
The Role of Provenance and Storage
When it comes to safeguarding investments Mudie states, “provenance and storage are critical to preserving a wine’s value.,” Fine wine must be sourced from official channels and stored professionally, ideally in UK bond with full insurance coverage. “Buying from individual collectors can be risky, especially when wine is stored in home cellars or wine fridges,” he cautions. For top-tier investments, professional storage and full provenance documentation are non-negotiable.
Climate Change: A Game-Changer for Wine Investment
Climate change is reshaping the wine world, and Mudie foresees its profound impact on rare wine values. "Extreme weather patterns are already driving up the value of rare wines," he points out. Frosts, droughts, and heatwaves are reducing yields and pushing up production costs. Mudie gives a striking example: “In 2021, frosts devastated up to 80% of production in parts of Bordeaux, Burgundy, and Champagne.”
As climate patterns become more erratic, Old World regions like Bordeaux and Burgundy will face increasing challenges. Meanwhile, cooler climate regions such as New Zealand, Canada, and even England are rising in prominence. However, while their wines are improving, Mudie remains cautious. "They are unlikely to be considered investment-grade anytime soon."
Emerging Markets: Beyond Bordeaux and Burgundy
Savvy investors looking beyond traditional powerhouses like Bordeaux and Burgundy should pay attention to Piedmont, according to Mudie. Particularly known for its Barolo, Piedmont’s Nebbiolo grape shares economic similarities with Burgundy’s Pinot Noir—both rely on single varietals that are difficult to grow and have a significant supply-demand imbalance. "As the price gap between Burgundy and Piedmont widens, the latter could attract a counterculture of collectors who avoid high-production regions like Bordeaux,” Mudie notes.
Expert Guidance: The Key to Success
Investing in fine wine is a sophisticated endeavor, and expert guidance can make all the difference. "Even in the stock market, where investors are rarely emotionally attached, it's difficult to remain objective," Mudie says. In the wine market, the challenge is magnified due to asymmetric access to information and the complexity of managing diverse portfolios.
For those seeking a hands-off approach, Savea offers a unique solution. Through innovative tokenization and smart contracts, Savea provides a scalable option for wine investors. "By replicating the performance of the Liv-ex 1000 index, which has averaged +7% annually over the last 20 years, Savea offers investors exposure to the asset class with lower costs, improved liquidity, and minimal barriers to entry—without the need to own the physical wine," explains Mudie.
As the fine wine market evolves, so too must the strategies of those investing in it. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a novice investor, the insights offered by Savea’s CEO Sam Mudie serve as a roadmap for successfully navigating the complex world of wine investment.
About the Author
Sam Mudie has worked in wine investment since 2012, including nine years with the world’s largest specialist advisor, Cult Wines, with US$360m assets under management. He founded the Singapore office, managed the business across Southeast Asia and was on the Investment Committee. During this time, he built up a large network of individuals with interests in various ‘passions assets’ such as wine, whisky, watches, art and cars. Sam has been featured in Robb Report, Forbes, MoneyFM, The Peak and CNA, and was previously a member of the British Chamber of Commerce’s Finance and Fintech Committee.
Introduction
When it comes to investing in rare fine wine, High Net Worth Individuals (HNWIs) often face a delicate balance between passion and pragmatism. For Sam Mudie, CEO of Savea, fine wine transcends mere capital growth, morphing into an obsession that unites people through craftsmanship and history. Yet, for those keen on long-term value appreciation, it’s critical to approach wine investment with an objective, strategic mindset.
As Mudie advises, “It’s crucial to separate heart from head." He emphasizes that personal preferences must be put aside, no matter how strong your love for certain regions or varietals may be. For instance, while one may not enjoy drinking Pinot Noir, the hard data from Liv-ex’s Burgundy 150 index shows an annualized return of 10% over the last 30 years. That’s a number impossible to ignore.
Strategic Diversification: A Recipe for Success
Diversification is key when it comes to wine investment. "Traditional collectors may focus on a few favourite regions or producers, but investors need a more strategic allocation," Mudie notes. Wine regions like Bordeaux, Burgundy, Champagne, and Tuscany are mainstays of fine wine investment, while emerging areas like Piedmont and Napa Valley provide unique opportunities. The trick is balancing producers and vintages to ensure price stability across market conditions. A diversified approach not only mitigates risk but also helps build a robust portfolio in a dynamic market.
Undervalued Regions: Where to Invest Next?
For those seeking undervalued regions, Mudie cautions against a hasty rush into Bordeaux, despite a 16% dip in the last two years. He explains, “Several overpriced vintage releases since 2021 have flooded the market, and a significant amount of stock remains unsold.” He advises holding off on Bordeaux investments until possibly mid-next year.
Burgundy and Champagne have come down approximately 25% from their peak in September 2022 and prices appear to be supported by very low supply, making them particularly attractive for investors looking for a likely market turn. "For these regions, now is an opportune moment to invest across most vintages," says Mudie.
Avoiding Novice Pitfalls
The allure of certain vintages often leads novice investors astray. According to Mudie, “One common mistake is assuming that the best vintage makes the best investment.” In reality, relative value and market sentiment are far more critical. As an example, he highlights the difference between Bordeaux’s 2010 and 2013 Lafite Rothschild vintages. While 2010 is regarded as a superior vintage, the 2013 vintage saw a 172% return between 2015 and 2022, compared to just 68% for the 2010 vintage. The key to this success was its lower starting price and the Hong Kong market's emphasis on brand over vintage quality at that time.
Portfolio Allocation: Where Does Wine Fit?
For HNWIs interested in adding wine to their broader investment portfolio, Mudie recommends integrating it within a diversified strategy. "Wealth managers typically suggest allocating around 20% to alternatives, which includes wine," Mudie says. While there's no one-size-fits-all rule, he stresses the importance of maintaining traditional, liquid assets alongside fine wine investments. A typical portfolio may include 40% in equities, 25% in bonds, 15% in property, and 20% in alternatives like wine, gold, or crypto.
The Role of Provenance and Storage
When it comes to safeguarding investments Mudie states, “provenance and storage are critical to preserving a wine’s value.,” Fine wine must be sourced from official channels and stored professionally, ideally in UK bond with full insurance coverage. “Buying from individual collectors can be risky, especially when wine is stored in home cellars or wine fridges,” he cautions. For top-tier investments, professional storage and full provenance documentation are non-negotiable.
Climate Change: A Game-Changer for Wine Investment
Climate change is reshaping the wine world, and Mudie foresees its profound impact on rare wine values. "Extreme weather patterns are already driving up the value of rare wines," he points out. Frosts, droughts, and heatwaves are reducing yields and pushing up production costs. Mudie gives a striking example: “In 2021, frosts devastated up to 80% of production in parts of Bordeaux, Burgundy, and Champagne.”
As climate patterns become more erratic, Old World regions like Bordeaux and Burgundy will face increasing challenges. Meanwhile, cooler climate regions such as New Zealand, Canada, and even England are rising in prominence. However, while their wines are improving, Mudie remains cautious. "They are unlikely to be considered investment-grade anytime soon."
Emerging Markets: Beyond Bordeaux and Burgundy
Savvy investors looking beyond traditional powerhouses like Bordeaux and Burgundy should pay attention to Piedmont, according to Mudie. Particularly known for its Barolo, Piedmont’s Nebbiolo grape shares economic similarities with Burgundy’s Pinot Noir—both rely on single varietals that are difficult to grow and have a significant supply-demand imbalance. "As the price gap between Burgundy and Piedmont widens, the latter could attract a counterculture of collectors who avoid high-production regions like Bordeaux,” Mudie notes.
Expert Guidance: The Key to Success
Investing in fine wine is a sophisticated endeavor, and expert guidance can make all the difference. "Even in the stock market, where investors are rarely emotionally attached, it's difficult to remain objective," Mudie says. In the wine market, the challenge is magnified due to asymmetric access to information and the complexity of managing diverse portfolios.
For those seeking a hands-off approach, Savea offers a unique solution. Through innovative tokenization and smart contracts, Savea provides a scalable option for wine investors. "By replicating the performance of the Liv-ex 1000 index, which has averaged +7% annually over the last 20 years, Savea offers investors exposure to the asset class with lower costs, improved liquidity, and minimal barriers to entry—without the need to own the physical wine," explains Mudie.
As the fine wine market evolves, so too must the strategies of those investing in it. Whether you’re a seasoned collector or a novice investor, the insights offered by Savea’s CEO Sam Mudie serve as a roadmap for successfully navigating the complex world of wine investment.
About the Author
Sam Mudie has worked in wine investment since 2012, including nine years with the world’s largest specialist advisor, Cult Wines, with US$360m assets under management. He founded the Singapore office, managed the business across Southeast Asia and was on the Investment Committee. During this time, he built up a large network of individuals with interests in various ‘passions assets’ such as wine, whisky, watches, art and cars. Sam has been featured in Robb Report, Forbes, MoneyFM, The Peak and CNA, and was previously a member of the British Chamber of Commerce’s Finance and Fintech Committee.
Get Exclusive Access
To The Full Report
Something else?
Multipolitan Passport Index
View Now
Explore the power of your passport with our comprehensive Passport Index.
Commentaries